For:
- non-Christians who don't understand what and how complementarians believe as they do.
- Christian egalitarians who think their complementarian siblings in Christ have lost their minds.
- complementarians, who perhaps haven't researched their own position.
The complementarian or traditional view (summarized from John Piper and Wayne
Grudem’s Recovering Biblical Manhood and
Womanhood) holds that a person’s “sexuality permeates one’s individual
being to its very depths.” To deny the behavioral patterns implied by this
“profound dimension of your personhood” dishonors both a person and his or her
maker, putting “strain on the humanity” of men and women alike. “Men and women
are of equal value and dignity in the eyes of God,” having both been made in
His image and although they have different roles, it should be noted that “[t]here
is no necessary relation between personal role and personal worth.” The
insistence that leadership or authority is positive while submission is
negative, is purely secular and unbiblical. Men and women both ought to conform
to God’s design because this is “fulfilling in the deepest sense of the word.”
Biblical
masculinity is a sense of “benevolent responsibility to lead, provide for and
protect women” within the context of their varied relationships. This
masculinity “accepts the burden of the final say in disagreements” and accepts
responsibility for the family’s spirituality. Men should set a “general tone
and pattern of initiative” in relationships with women.
Biblical
femininity is “a freeing disposition to affirm, receive and nurture strength
and leadership from worth men” within the context of their varied relationships.
Even if a woman might be in a position of authority over a man (a principle
over male teacher, for example), she should affirm his unique role to protect
and lead her through a general disposition to yield. Wives should act as though“[her
husband’s] needs set [her] agenda.”
These beliefs are undoubtedly countercultural,
but are derived mainly from the Genesis creation account of mankind. Man was
created first and enjoyed a special relationship with God. It was Adam alone
who named the animals in the garden and to Adam alone that God ordered not to
eat of the tree of good and evil. (Genesis 2) Woman was created “for man,” not
man for woman (I Cor 11:2). He named her, she came from her. Several of the early church letters encourage women to
submit to the authority of the male counterparts in both marriage and worship
practices. (I Tim 2:11-15, I Cor 11 and 14) No women were chosen as leaders or
apostles in the gospels, nor were any of the original seven deacons women.
(Acts 7)
Have I lost you all to boredom yet? Hopefully not. For my opinion/analysis, check out part 2.
Have I lost you all to boredom yet? Hopefully not. For my opinion/analysis, check out part 2.
No comments:
Post a Comment